VARsenal

The Madueke Masterclass in Falling

Bayer Leverkusen 1–1 Arsenal | Champions League R16 | 11 March 2026

Arsenal were losing 1-0 when Noni Madueke went to ground under minimal contact from Malik Tillman in the penalty area. The referee pointed to the spot. Havertz scored. Arsenal drew. The football world erupted. Ex-PGMOL chief Keith Hackett called it outright "SIMULATION". Multiple pundits said Madueke should have been booked. Arteta, meanwhile, threatened to boycott the second leg because VAR didn't give them another penalty.

"He should be booked for simulation, yet gets rewarded with a penalty. Football — it's getting unwatchable." — Football fan reaction, widely shared

ESPN's VAR review confirmed Arsenal were "fortunate" to receive the penalty. Martin Keown said it was a penalty. Martin Keown always says it's a penalty.

The Havertz Phantom Booking

Bayer Leverkusen 1–1 Arsenal | Champions League R16 | 11 March 2026

In the 94th minute, referee Halil Umut Meler showed Kai Havertz a yellow card after an Arsenal corner. The reason? Nobody knows. Havertz was simply standing in the box while Alejandro Grimaldo had his hands around him. He had his back to the ball. He wasn't arguing. The official Sofascore reason was listed as an "argument" — but no argument was visible. Even Arsenal fans couldn't explain it. Havertz himself looked baffled.

"It was one of the most baffling refereeing decisions I have ever seen. Havertz simply stood in the box while having Grimaldo's hands around him." — Arsenal Insider

The irony? Arsenal had spent the week being accused of grappling at corners. The referee, apparently overcorrecting, booked the Arsenal player who was being grabbed.

The Everton Ankle Stamp Cover-Up

Arsenal 2–0 Everton | Premier League | 14 March 2026

In the 24th minute, Kai Havertz was sent through on goal and had his left ankle stamped on by Michael Keane inside the penalty area. The referee waved play on. VAR reviewed it and confirmed the decision — no penalty. Havertz was incensed. Replays clearly showed Keane's foot landing on Havertz's ankle. Arsenal won 2-0 anyway (thanks to 16-year-old Max Dowman), but the penalty denial dominated post-match discussion.

"An absolute disgrace. The replays clearly show the contact on Havertz's ankle. VAR has to intervene there." — Jamie Redknapp, Sky Sports

The Premier League Match Centre issued a statement saying the contact from Keane was "not intentional" — a curious standard given that intent is not required for a penalty to be awarded.

The Everton Christmas Robbery

Everton 0–1 Arsenal | Premier League | 20 December 2025

William Saliba kicked Thierno Barry's calf inside the penalty area. The referee didn't give it. VAR didn't intervene. Arsenal won 1-0 and spent Christmas Day at the top of the Premier League table. Two weeks later, the Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel voted 3-2 that it was a penalty and that VAR should have sent the referee to the monitor.

"Had the penalty decision gone the way of Everton, Arsenal would have made the trip back to London with just one point." — Sports Illustrated

The Saliba Headbutt Penalty

Brighton 1–1 Arsenal | Premier League | January 2025

Brighton were awarded a penalty when William Saliba appeared to make unintentional contact with Joao Pedro while trying to win a header. Replays showed Saliba got a slight touch on the ball first. The VAR took just seven seconds to confirm the decision. Arsenal, who had been leading 1-0, drew the match and dropped two more precious points.

"VAR took just seven seconds to determine Brighton's controversial penalty against Arsenal was correct to be given." — Sky Sports

The Declan Rice "Pass"

Brighton 1–1 Arsenal | Premier League | August 2024

Declan Rice received a second yellow card for kicking the ball away — a decision so minimal that Arteta later claimed Rice had simply "passed the ball." Arsenal had been leading 1-0 and ended up drawing, losing two vital points. Two games later, Leandro Trossard did the same thing against Manchester City (this time, he definitely kicked it) and received the same punishment. Arsenal drew again.

"He passed the ball." — Mikel Arteta, with a completely straight face

The Lewis-Skelly Red Card (That Wasn't)

Arsenal vs Wolves | Premier League | January 2025

Myles Lewis-Skelly was shown a straight red card for a professional foul on Matt Doherty — a challenge that, by any reasonable standard, was a yellow card. The red card was later overturned on appeal. This was the only VAR error the Premier League's Key Match Incidents Panel admitted went against Arsenal in the entire 2024-25 season. Just one. Out of the entire season.

"A yellow card is far more in keeping with how the game is refereed in the Premier League." — Dale Johnson, ESPN VAR Review

The Martinelli Madness

Arsenal vs Liverpool | Premier League | January 2026

Gabriel Martinelli caused a major controversy when he kicked Conor Bradley while the Liverpool player was already down injured. Arteta's defence? "He didn't realise." Martinelli later apologised. Roy Keane called it "disgraceful." Arne Slot, Liverpool's manager, took the diplomatic route and defended Martinelli. The incident sparked a wider debate about Arsenal's conduct on the pitch.

"He didn't realise." — Mikel Arteta, Arsenal Manager